Why Downtown Scotch Plains Has to Move Its Police Station Before It Gets Its New Town Square

November 5, 2026

The first construction in Scotch Plains' downtown redevelopment won't happen downtown. The township's own schedule starts with a new Public Safety Building on Plainfield Avenue. The Park Avenue town square, the part shown in most renderings, sits on the current Town Hall and fire department block, and it can only begin after the police, fire, EMS and the Rescue Squad have moved into their new building. Mayor Josh Losardo wrote in May that the safety building's groundbreaking was planned for "next year." He estimated about two years to build it.

If you're comparing Scotch Plains with Westfield, Cranford or Fanwood, that order matters more than the renderings. A groundbreaking in 2027 and a two-year build mean the developer's first downtown phase starts around 2029 at the earliest. The full plan is estimated at seven to ten years. The downtown you walk through this fall is close to the one you'll have for the next several years. The two new apartment buildings that opened in 2026 came from a separate track, which is why they got here so much sooner.

Two buildings opened this year because nobody had to move out first

Scotch Plains cut two ribbons on new housing in 2026, and neither was part of the big downtown plan.

Scotch Plains Crossing at 1776 East Second Street opened on April 8. Elite Properties built it on three vacant properties under a redevelopment plan the Township Council adopted in 2022 for the East Second Street corridor. It has 40 units, six of them designated affordable, plus 2,140 square feet of commercial space and heated indoor parking.

18 FIFTEEN at 1815 Front Street followed on October 6. TAPinto reported that the three-story building has 42 studio, one-, two- and three-bedroom apartments. Nine are designated affordable and count toward the township's state-mandated obligation. Owner and developer Ted Schiller, a lifelong Scotch Plains resident, joined township officials at the ribbon cutting. The township's redevelopment page traces the project to a 2020 ordinance.

Together that's 82 new apartments within walking distance of Park Avenue in a single year. Both projects went up on land with no municipal department on it. Once the plans and approvals were done, a builder could start. The Woodmont Properties plan doesn't work that way.

The plaza block is where Town Hall sits now

In 2023 the township chose Woodmont Properties as its designated redeveloper, after a 2022 request for qualifications drew 11 candidates. The plan covers three districts. The mayor's May 22 message spells out what sits on each one today.

  • District B is the current Town Hall, fire department and the surface lot next to them. It is planned for 213 residential units, 419 parking spaces with ground-floor spaces reserved for public use, about 10,000 square feet of retail, and the new town square on Park Avenue.
  • District C is reserved for municipal use. It gets a new combined library and town hall facing Bartle Avenue, plus the required public parking.
  • District A is where the Scotch Plains Library and its parking lot sit now, on Bartle and Forest Avenues. It is planned for 137 residential units and 251 parking spaces.

The headline part of the plan, the plaza, sits on land the township itself occupies. Nothing goes up on that block until the township has somewhere else to go. Police and the Office of Emergency Management currently work out of 430 Park Avenue. Their new home is planned for 2406, 2416 and 2450 Plainfield Avenue.

TAPinto's account of the May 18 public session gives the order like this:

  1. Build the new Public Safety Building on Plainfield Avenue and move police, fire and rescue into it.
  2. Start District B, the Park Avenue plaza block, as Woodmont's first phase.
  3. Finish District C, including a public parking deck, then move the library and town hall straight into the new building.
  4. Build District A.

The third step explains the fourth. The mayor wrote that the new library and town hall will be finished before municipal offices move, so the township won't need to lease temporary space. That saves rent, and it also means the library stays where it is until its replacement opens. Since District A is the library site, it has to come last.

Putting the plan on a calendar

Here is how the stated plans line up against today's date. Every date below comes from a township statement. None of them is a construction contract.

  • Plainfield Avenue now: The township calls the Public Safety Building project "still in the design and planning phase." Its plans and elevations are conceptual and will go to the Planning Board when a site plan is filed. The Township Council approved the amended redevelopment plan for the three Plainfield Avenue parcels on October 28, 2025, and the building is meant to be built in one phase.
  • 2027: Groundbreaking on the safety building is planned, per the May 22 message.
  • About two years after that: The safety building is finished and emergency services move in. Then Woodmont can start District B, which puts the plaza's start around 2029 if the stated schedule holds.
  • Seven to ten years overall: Full build-out, per the township's estimate.

State permits also stand between the plan and a shovel. The township's redevelopment page says the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection issued a Line Verification Approval in 2024, and that the township and Woodmont are still working with the department on the Individual Permit approvals the project needs. The mayor's October 9 message mentions the downtown plan again but gives no new milestone after the May presentation.

The long schedule follows from how the plan was designed. The township chose to build on its own parcels and surface lots. The mayor wrote that "no private properties are taken or negatively impacted" and that the plan "is centered entirely on township-owned parcels and surface parking lots." Building only on its own land meant moving its own departments first, and that is why the schedule runs long.

What the finished version adds, and what holds steady meanwhile

The end state is specific. According to TAPinto, the new square would pair with the Alan Augustine Village Green for farmers markets, music and movie nights. A "flush" driveway could close during events to make room for bigger festivals, and the design calls for shade trees, flexible seating and an interactive fountain. The plan also includes curb extensions and traffic calming at Forest Street and Bartle Avenue. The mayor added that Woodmont is working on a liquor license for a dining spot on the plaza.

Parking is the piece most likely to matter while construction is underway. The plan commits to replacing public parking one-for-one in all three districts, with public spaces on the garage ground floors. The surface lots behind Town Hall and the library will turn into structured garages over time, and the order of construction decides which lot changes first.

Until then, downtown keeps its current shape, and new places are opening in the existing buildings. On Saturday, November 7, the Fall Artisan Market runs from 8 a.m. to 1 p.m. in the municipal lot at 430 Park Avenue, Patch reports. Sushi BBY Omakase opened at 1832 East Second Street with reservation-only, 12- or 17-course chef's-choice dinners, BYOB. Meet Again Café opened on Route 22 at 1985 US-22, in the former Dunkin' building, after an August 18 ribbon cutting, according to TAPinto.

The next public decision point is in December

The township is updating its Master Plan, the state-required roadmap for land use that each municipality revisits every ten years, and aims to adopt it by a December deadline. The mayor's October 9 message stresses that the Master Plan "does not rezone properties." In the Planning Board's resident survey, 79% of respondents said they were satisfied or extremely satisfied with quality of life in Scotch Plains, and the downtown was one of the top issues they raised.

The May 22 message also promised three more public information sessions, on the project's finances, the Public Safety Building, and the new library and town hall in District C. The Public Safety Building session will say the most about timing, because every later phase waits on that building.

Questions buyers ask about the downtown plan

Will the redevelopment take any homes? According to the mayor's May 22 message, no. The plan uses only township-owned parcels and surface parking lots.

Which part of downtown changes first? Plainfield Avenue, where the Public Safety Building is planned. The Park Avenue plaza block comes second, once emergency services have moved.

How many new apartments are in the Woodmont plan? The May presentation listed 213 units in District B and 137 in District A, or 350 in total. These are proposal figures and could change as the plan moves through permits and site-plan review.

Are the 2026 apartment buildings part of the Woodmont plan? No. Scotch Plains Crossing and 18 FIFTEEN came from separate, earlier redevelopment plans for East Second Street and Front Street.

If you own a home near Park Avenue, Bartle Avenue or Plainfield Avenue and wonder how a buyer will see a seven-to-ten-year build-out down the street, I'm glad to talk it through with you. I can show you how today's sales near downtown are priced and how the redevelopment schedule fits into that. Jayne Bernstein offers thoughtful, neighbor-to-neighbor guidance. Request your home valuation and we'll start with what your house is worth today.

Work With Us

Their industry specialities include luxury homes, relocations, estate sales and investment properties. With 16 years of experience in the real estate industry, she has been through multiple market cycles as an agent, buyer and investor, and has a deep understanding for the often-complicated process that her clients will encounter.

Contact Us

Follow Us On Instagram